CLICK HERE FOR BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND MYSPACE LAYOUTS »

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Amazing thing!

So today in my english class we were talking about different types of definition arguements, and my teacher decided that Universal Healthcare was a great topic to use as an example. Being the typical teacher that most professors are he has a more liberal viewpoint of everything. He showed us a clip from YouTube about some antidepressant drugs that actually are being proven that they are more harmful to you than helpful. Like if you go on the drug, it is very addicting, and won't help forever, probably due to the fact that your body will change when you take drugs. anyway, they interviewed a woman who tried for 8 years to get off the drug in lots of different ways, but none of them ever helped.
they then talked about how there are studies proving that the drug will cause you to be more suicidal, depressed and violent. the clip was from fox news and my teacher just loves to try to put down the network. so he called this type of video more use of scare tactics than informing, which can be seen since it was only a 3 minute clip. all networks will use the amount of time they can get and since they only had so much time to fit in all this, they had to shove as much as they can into it. Anyway when we took a break in class some of us started talking about the debate on universal healthcare, and one person asked why it was so bad. i said that it doesn't work for all countries, like canada, whose people spend so much time on the waiting list that by the time they get to the doctors or the bed they are beyond help. i mean most of them will come down here for help if they need it.
one of the guys in the class spoke up and asked me if i had ever lived in a country that had universal health care, and no i haven't. he then told me of his dad and how he fell off the roof or something and got hurt bad, spent 2 weeks in the hospital and had to pay nothing for it. he said that the only thing he doesn't like about America is that the healthcare is so expensive. I said that it may work for other countries, but because of so many things here, it would not work. i didn't say this next part. Maybe if each state figured their own way of taking care of healthcare, maybe it would work, but forcing a whole country to do it at huge prices is crazy. not only would we be giving to people who aren't working at all and need to pick up the slack and find a job and put some effort into their own lives, or illeagle aliens who shouldn't even be here.
anyway after that last part the conversation died down real quick. after class i went out in the hall and sat down to wait for my friend Maria to get there since her next class was in the classroom i was just in, and that same guy came and apologized for jumping on me for that. We agreed that the people higher up in the government weren't looking out for the people they are supposed to be serving. we also agreed that it is okay to have your own opinion and it's okay to express it. Wow! i never would have expected a fellow student to come to me and apologizing for jumping on me for what i was saying! you know, there are some good people out there who may disagree with me, but we don't need to hate each other for having a different opinion!

5 comments:

D'N'J said...

except that he did pay for it in all his taxes up to the point where he needed the care. i'm upset about the waiting lines and stuff, but what upsets me more is that people don't seem to realize that you really ARE paying for the care. it's so tough because it's sort of like insurance - let's say on your house. you pay and pay and pay every month to make sure that if something happens, you can get some help restoring your life. well, what happens when you never have the house burn down, that money may be all wasted (in your mind, some people might say that's good, depends on the person) the real issue is that deciding to put that money into your house insurance is YOUR choice, not anyone else's. i don't think it's fair to make us invest our money into thousands and thousands of people who will not get sick. people should be allowed to shop around for insurance for themselves and invest in themselves.

whew! that topic really makes me mad.

Elicia said...

yeah! but you sure made a good point that i didn't even think about, that you are paying, just in taxes. i'll have to keep that in mind when i do get into a conversation like that! :) i just thought it was amazing that he apologized!

Barb said...

Amen D. We're supposed to be self-sufficient. I like the fact that I'm the consumer as far as my health care goes. It means I get to go to a dr I like, they have to impress me, or I will change dr's.

We were adjusting are car insurance the other day and the guy on the phone was treating me like crap - I had to remind him I was the consumer and the reason he had a job, and he better start doing what I asked or I would talk to his supervisor and change insurance companies. He apologized real fast.

People...

Troy said...

Don't forget you have grandparents that spent a long time living in Canada under their health care.

Plus the plus Prime Minister Danny Williams of Canada decided to trust the good ol' USA over Canada when he needed heart surgery. That speaks volumes!

D'N'J said...

yeah, sorry, i didn't mean to glaze over the real fact in your entry, which was really nice of that guy. that definitely never happened in my liberal governments class in oregon! i just go riled up with the conversation.